Alright, I think my full opinion on this matter needs to be said. The Nether does act like a reszone. Players go there to acquire the blocks that spawn in that world, and take them to the overworld to build.
There are no lots there, so you shouldn't have to rely on the nether to create bases. Why not do that in reszone as well? Perhaps you should make your bases in freebuild? They can be griefed just like they can in the Nether.
The Nether is not any one person's, so don't call it your own. The nether is to be shared with everyone, which means that regenning it will make new resources available to users.
You know why we reset the reszone all the time? Because players are too "lazy" to wander out further than maybe 500 blocks looking for new materials. They want to be close by the spawn it seems. That's why they want to push for a Nether regeneration. Honestly, I have no problems with this. Those who made nether wart farms would have to bank their warts, and find a new spot when the regeneration is complete.
I absolutely will not tolerate holding off on doing something because a few members claim that they own part of the Nether. No one owns it.
Perhaps TinyWE should be allowed there with 10x its ability removed?
My opinion is to either regen the nether, or move the spawn.