This is ridiculous. The argument went on for a funnily long amount of time. Yes, "good" is subjective. Well, DUH, Sherlock. I think that paying taxes is good because it goes towards a good cause, supporting the government. It's patriotic. In that same way, donating to the server is a good cause. It's... patriotic? Anyway, this ban is still silly and should be repealed.
I have stated (and not been punished) after saying that Goldy is a huge waste of money for at least 75% of people. It is, I truly think so. Heck, it was probably a waste of money for me. Discussing things should not be against the rules. Some servers have "no discussing politics/religion" rules; even mentioning them can result in a ban. This server doesn't, which is sort of why I prefer it over others. Keep it that way.
I am ssooo glad the chatlogs have been shown. Please, admins, always show chatlogs to the public when a ban is in question.